Have you played the Halo 3 Beta yet?
If you answered yes, then you are either a sucker, or lucky.
It seems only those people are getting in.
First, the suckers. All those people who bought Crackdown for a guaranteed Beta invite are suckers. If you bought Crackdown 'cause it looked like a fun game to play, then you are not a sucker. Spending $60 for a Beta invite is suckerish.
Next, the lucky. There were, for numbers sake, lets say around 25,000 people who could get into the Beta without having to buy a thing. There were three ways, being one of the first to sign-up at Halo3.com and being chosen...so-called Phase 1, the Rule of Three (basically playing Halo 2 for three hours, being one of the first 13,333 people to sign up...and something else), and Friends and Family. Out of those three groups, only one could be considered a success, and that's the Friends and Family group. They all, seemingly, got their Beta invite. Even if not all the Friends and Family did get an invite, no one will really know as there wasn't an official sign-up or anything. Meanwhile, there are more then a few Phase 1 and Rule of Three people who are left out in the cold without a Beta invite. So, what gives?
Granted, SOME Phase 1 and Rule of Three people have gotten an invite and are indeed playing the Beta, but what about the rest?
There was an error in some code somewhere within Crackdown that prevented ALL Crackdown owners from accessing the Beta. Within a few hours that problem was traced, fixed, tested, and made public. So if you paid your $60 for Crackdown, you're in. If you put in a good few hours online trying for Phase 1 or Rule of Three...you're probably shit outta luck. What's up with that?
Bungie isn't really to blame here, this whole Beta invite thing was handled by Microsoft. What does Microsoft have to say about all of this? Not a damn thing so far. Call up Microsoft and complain, plead, and cajole for an Beta invite and they can do nothing for you. Some are reporting that even though they got an email saying they were "in on the Beta", with their gamertag included in the email even, there is no record of that gamertag being linked to the Beta. No record? What type of system has Microsoft got going on where there is no record, even though you inputted your gamertag and email address in the same form? Why is Microsoft being so mum about this situation? Why is Bungie adding to the flames against them by staying mum themselves? In the eyes of many, they are not free from guilt, but are rolled into the one entity that is Microsoft.
How soon will this all be resolved? Probably never unless Microsoft changes its approach. For one, the end-users who are expecting those emails are to blame. The 'accepted' email, and a follow-up email, clearly stated to add two separate email address to the "not spam" list or your own contacts list, just so any future emails would show up in your main folder, not a junk or spam folder. And yet, many people found their Beta invite email sitting in the spam/junk folder like some hot stock tip email. You can't expect Microsoft to go to everyone's house and unblock the email for them. Because the end-user didn't follow directions, some aggressive ISPs have blocked the email from ever even getting to the user...a step further then kicking suspect files to the trash, its kicking suspect files out of the neighbourhood. Ouch.
What will bring salvation to Microsoft and Bungie, and stop, probably, a ten-thousand plus army of disgruntled players from their witch hunt? My guess? A Marketplace download. Forgo this 'code' nonsense and let whomever wants to play the game, play the damn game. Its not as if getting to play in the Beta is really a special treat or anything, its not as if you are sitting with the developers looking over your shoulder notepad in hand jotting down any bugs they spot. Bugs will be found and bugs will be squashed, but this isn't a true Beta in the traditional sense , the Halo 3 Beta is more like an unpolished Demo. It's not a cop-out, mind you, from a polished demo, as behind-the-scene bug-squashing is going on, but at the same time, there is more to do in this "Beta" then in other Demos that were released less then a week before the "Beta" and whose final game is coming out before the end of this month, as opposed to more then three months for Halo 3.
Let the people have their Beta and you will find salvation.
In the end, this whole Beta ordeal is just a minor error somewhere, but the closed lips and hype surrounding the Beta are fanning the flames of hate. Those flames are hot, but not well rooted. However, unless appropriate measures are taken quickly, those flames will root and spread, um...like wild fire, and even if the flames don't getcha, the smoke will. Not many people are hurt from flames, but many are hurt from the smoke.